Every pool loses some water to sun and wind. But if you are topping off more than about an inch a week, especially in cool weather, that is usually a real leak, not evaporation. The good news is you can learn a lot about where it is before anyone touches a shovel. All it takes is a pencil, two days of patience and a few threaded plugs.
Watch the two-minute walkthrough, then use the written steps below.
What you need
- A pencil or a strip of tape and a waterproof marker
- A ruler or tape measure
- Two days with no rain in the forecast and no swimming
- Threaded expansion plugs sized for your fittings. Most returns take a 1.5 inch plug once the eyeball fitting is off. Many skimmers take a 1.5 inch or 2 inch plug in the floor hole. Pool supply stores carry them.
- Your autofill turned off, if you have one, so it can't quietly hide the loss
Step 1: Check the pump pad first
Before any water test, walk the equipment pad. Look for drips at the pump lid, unions, valves and the filter, and watch the backwash line while the pump runs. A backwash line that drips while the filter is running is a confirmed leak, and it is often the easiest fix of all. Also look for wet soil or extra green grass between the pool and the pad.
Step 2: Mark the water level with the pump running
Fill the pool to its normal level, about halfway up the skimmer opening. Draw a fine pencil line (or place a strip of tape) at the water level on the skimmer wall. Let the pump run around the clock for a full 24 hours. Then come back and mark the new level.
Step 3: Mark it again with the pump off
Reset to the same starting level if you need to, and draw a fresh line. Shut the pump off and leave everything quiet for another 24 hours. No swimming, no topping off. Mark the level again and measure both drops.
If you want to rule out evaporation completely, run a bucket test at the same time. A bucket of pool water on the step loses only to evaporation, so any extra loss in the pool is the leak.
Step 4: Read the two pencil lines
The gap between the two marks carries most of the clues.
| What you see | What it points to | Where to look |
|---|---|---|
| More loss with the pump running | Pressure leak | Return lines, deck jets, slide or water feature lines, the pressure side at the pad |
| More loss with the pump off | Suction leak | Skimmer line or main drain line |
| About the same loss either way | Structural leak | Shell cracks, light niche or gasket, fittings, a hydrostatic valve in the main drain |
Step 5: Plug the returns (for a pressure leak)
Turn the pump off. Unscrew the eyeball fitting from each return and thread a plug in by hand until it is snug. Do this on every return so the whole return side is sealed. Then run another 24 hour level check.
If the pool holds its level with every return sealed, the leak is inside a return pipe, underground or under the deck, not in the shell. That narrows a dig, or a no-dig repair, to one line instead of guessing.
Step 6: Plug the skimmer and main drain (for a suction leak)
With the pump off, pull the skimmer basket and thread the correctly sized plug into the hole in the bottom of the skimmer, hand tight and fully seated. Check the level over the next day.
If it is still dropping, the main drain is next. That means going to the deep end floor, removing the drain cover screws and seating a plug in the drain opening. Only do this if you are a confident swimmer, have someone watching and are sure the pump is off and cannot turn on. Many owners leave this step to a pro.
Step 7: If it is structural, inspect the shell
When the loss is the same with the pump on or off, the water is usually leaving through the pool itself. Look closely at:
- Hairline cracks in plaster or around steps
- The light niche and the light's gasket and cord seal
- Skimmer throats where they meet the shell
- Return and fitting seals
- Vinyl liners pulling away at the track, or small tears near steps and fittings
A few drops of food coloring or test dye squeezed near a suspect spot on a calm day will show you if the water is being pulled in. See our guide on when to patch or replace a vinyl liner if your pool is vinyl.
Safety and common mistakes
- Never work on fittings or drains with the pump running.
- Don't overtighten plugs. Hand tight and seated is enough, and cracked fittings make a new leak.
- Don't test in rain or right after heavy swimming. Start over if either happens.
- Don't plug the skimmer and leave the pump on. The pump can run dry and burn up.
- Write down your measurements and take photos of each pencil line. They make any later visit much faster.
What the test can't tell you
The pencil and plug tests tell you which side of the system is leaking, and often which line. They can't show the exact spot along a buried pipe. That takes pressure testing each line and electronic listening equipment. When you get there, our pool leak detection page explains how a line is isolated and pinpointed, and our guide to pool leak detection methods covers the questions worth asking any company. If a buried line is the culprit, it can often be lined from the inside with no digging.
One pencil, two marks, one plug, and you have named the leak before anyone starts digging.
Frequently asked questions
How much water loss is normal for a pool? It depends on sun, wind and humidity. In cool weather, losing more than about an inch a week is a strong sign of a leak. In hot summer weather, compare against a bucket test before deciding.
Do I really need two separate 24 hour tests? Yes. Comparing pump on against pump off is what separates pressure side leaks from suction side and structural leaks. One test only tells you the pool is losing water.
What size plugs do I need for pool returns? Most returns take a 1.5 inch threaded plug once the eyeball fitting is removed. Skimmer floor holes are often 1.5 inch or 2 inch. Check your fittings or take one to a pool supply store.
Is it safe to plug the main drain myself? Only if the pump is off and can't turn on, you are a confident swimmer and someone is watching. The drain is at the deepest point, so many owners leave this step to a professional.
What if the pool still loses water with every line plugged? Then the leak is most likely structural: the shell, the light niche, a fitting or a hydrostatic valve. A careful dye test around those spots, or a professional leak detection visit, is the next step.
Shared by The Leak Geeks, Leaktronics Certified leak detection in West Columbia, SC. Questions about your results? Call 803-570-5283.
